Investment Research with Banyantree
How we research investments, and how you can use the work
Since 2015 we’ve produced cross-asset research for professional investors who want another view alongside their own: advisers, investment committees, family offices and institutions. It covers Australian and global companies, managed funds, ETFs, hybrids, listed property and listed investment companies, as well as major economies and asset allocation.
The people who write it also act on it: the research informs the portfolios we manage, so we concentrate on ideas we’d be prepared to invest in. One small team covers companies, funds, hybrids and the economy, so a rise in interest rates gets weighed for an operating company, a property trust and a hybrid by the same people. You speak to whoever wrote the note, with no relationship manager in between. Fund managers, issuers and platforms don’t pay us for research coverage, inclusion or placement.
Short on time? Read Chapter 1 for what you receive, Chapter 8 for the research itself, and Chapter 10 for price, independence and conflicts.
Research examples in this Guide are dated and record what we concluded at the time. Their ratings, prices and targets are from those dates and aren’t current recommendations. The research service is for wholesale clients and professional investors.
Chapter 01
What we publish and when
On the afternoon of Thursday 10 April 2025, we sent subscribers a Quick Update asking whether the bottom was in. Overnight, the US had paused most of its new tariffs, and the ASX 200 closed that day about 4.5% higher. The update set down what we’d been telling clients in meetings over the previous week, as markets fell: the sell-off in February and March had been fairly targeted, but within a few days in April it had turned indiscriminate. It also looked at the number of NYSE-listed securities making new 52-week lows. When that count passes 270, many investors treat it as a warning, and the update called a count near 700 “normally a decent indicator” of buy-signal territory. On 7 April it stood at 640, against an average of about 57 over the previous eight years.
Our view was that clients with the risk appetite and the liquidity should dust off their shopping list and consider some allocation to equities.
Source: Banyantree Investment Group, Quick Update email, 10 April 2025, with Bloomberg’s count of new 52-week lows on the NYSE. Edited extract. The ASX 200’s move that day is from market reports.
We publish research at different frequencies because investment questions develop at different speeds. A Quick Update goes out the same day. A company note takes longer, and a quarterly strategy paper longer again.
What arrives, and when
Our publication programme.
Following markets through the day
Morning Report
The Morning Report prepares you for the Australian trading day. It covers international equities, government bonds, currencies, commodities, economic releases and relevant company developments. Where a market has moved substantially, it gives context for that movement and asks whether the news behind it matters beyond the immediate price response.
Our Morning Report of 10 December 2024 covered the rally in Hong Kong shares after Chinese policymakers signalled a more accommodative stance. The Hang Seng had risen 2.8% after the Politburo said it would adopt a “moderately loose” monetary policy in 2025. China’s producer prices had fallen 2.5% on a year earlier, a 26th straight month of factory-gate deflation, and consumer inflation had slowed to 0.2%. The People’s Bank of China had added gold to its reserves for the first time in seven months. At home, Beach Energy had fallen 4.2% after flagging quality issues at its Waitsia plant and adjusting its guidance for first gas, and the RBA’s cash rate decision was due that day.
The policy signal had improved market sentiment, while the producer-price data continued to point to weakness in the underlying economy. The report brought both into view before the Australian open.
Source: Banyantree Investment Group, Morning Report, 10 December 2024. Edited extract; the market tables are omitted.
Intraday Report
The Intraday Report follows important movements during the Australian trading session, including sectors and individual companies. It lists the five best and five worst performers in the ASX 200 with the news behind the biggest moves, adds a chart of the day, and runs an options watch that shows where open interest is concentrated and flags unusual trades.
Recurring valuation work in specialist listed markets
The weekly research programme covers ASX-listed hybrids, Australian real estate investment trusts and listed investment companies. These markets have different characteristics, but each benefits from regular comparison, because the relationship between market price and underlying value changes even when the investment itself has changed relatively little.
Two hybrids from issuers with similar credit profiles can still have materially different terms, so we compare each security’s yield with its ranking, distribution terms and call dates. For A-REITs, we set the quoted distribution yield against the properties supporting the income and the trust’s financial commitments. A LIC’s shares trade above or below the reported net tangible assets of its portfolio, and we track that premium or discount and what’s driving it.
Chapters 4 and 5 explain what we look for in each market.
Monthly research: markets, the newsletter and the webinar
The Market Wrap brings together important movements and changes across Australian and international financial markets. The Monthly Investment Letter takes the month’s main questions further, and the subject matter changes with the evidence.
The April 2025 issue, then titled Investment Newsletter, covered the sharp escalation of the US-China tariff dispute, revised IMF global growth expectations and the policies on offer in the Australian federal election campaign. Its headline, echoing a remark by the US Treasury Secretary, called the tariff stand-off with China unsustainable. It set out the reciprocal tariffs announced on 2 April, the 90-day pause that followed and signs that the US was ready to pare back its 145% tariffs on Chinese goods. The IMF had just cut its global growth estimate to 2.8% from 3.3%, and forward-looking business sentiment had fallen sharply. The long read matched each major party’s election policies to the sectors they’d affect, from banks and insurers to REITs, retailers and power, and cautioned against making major portfolio changes before the vote.
Source: Banyantree Investment Group, Investment Newsletter, April 2025. Edited extract.
The Monthly Investment Series is a live webinar where we talk through the economy, asset allocation, equities, and funds and ETFs, sometimes with a guest speaker, and take subscribers’ questions.
Quarterly research: economics, strategy and asset allocation
Our quarterly research takes a broader view of the investment environment. The macroeconomic work covers growth, inflation, employment, monetary policy and financial conditions across major economies. The strategy and asset-allocation research looks at how those developments interact with market valuations, and at the opportunities and risks across asset classes.
Our Multi-Asset Strategy Quarterly #29, issued on 5 November 2024 before the result of the US presidential election was known, weighed alternative political outcomes alongside employment data, equity valuations and bond-market term premiums. It’s in Chapter 8.
Research produced when the question warrants it
The regular schedule accounts for much of the programme. The rest follows particular investments, market events and questions that need more time: a result that changes our earnings assumptions, a refinancing, a manager meeting that raises questions about a fund, or a fall in price that changes the return on offer.
Detailed research reports
Company research covers the business, financial position, earnings prospects, valuation and risks. The work involves reviewing financial statements and forecasts, meeting management or specialists, and comparing an investment with the alternatives. Fund and ETF research starts elsewhere: the underlying holdings, investment process, manager, costs, liquidity and sources of risk matter more than the performance figures that are easiest to find.
Thematic reports look at how an emerging theme affects markets, sectors, companies and credit. We also report on company meetings, site visits and our research trips overseas.
Quick Updates and investment ideas
Some developments need a shorter message. A Quick Update brings a specific market observation or investment question to subscribers while it’s still relevant, like the one that opens this chapter. An investment idea communicates the conclusion of more detailed work and sends readers to the accompanying note.
On 23 April 2025, we distributed an Australian income investment idea after publishing a detailed company report on Deterra Royalties that morning. Deterra held a portfolio of mining royalties across 11 countries and six commodities. The email described 28 royalty assets, with the Mining Area C iron-ore royalty in the Pilbara, operated by BHP, as its largest contributor.
The share price had weakened. Iron ore was one reason, because the shares tracked the iron-ore price closely. The acquisition of Trident Royalties was the other: it broadened Deterra’s portfolio but increased gearing, which remained well within management’s target range and covenants. Our view was that the share price already reflected much of the downside risk, and we published a Buy recommendation with a price target of A$4.23. The email also compared royalty ownership with mining shares and commodity ETFs, on their exposure to commodity prices, operating costs and income.
The email gave subscribers the recommendation and the main reasons in a few paragraphs; the report carried the full analysis.
Source: Banyantree Investment Group, Deterra Royalties investment idea email and company report, 23 April 2025. Edited extract. The Buy recommendation and A$4.23 target are from that date.
Chapter 02
What we cover and how we choose it
The research universe is much larger than the number of investments receiving detailed analysis at any one time. As at November 2025, about 2,700 listed companies passed through our screens. Between 120 and 150 Australian companies and 30 to 50 global companies were under full coverage, each with a written note on our thesis and valuation at least twice a year. The work comes in three levels. A company in the screen has been looked at. A company under coverage has a current note on our thesis and valuation. A published recommendation means we’ve done the detailed work and are prepared to stand behind a view at that price.
The breadth of the research universe
As at November 2025.
Our data comes from Bloomberg, FactSet, Haver Analytics, BCA Research and Alpine. Before we do deep work on a company, it goes through our own rating system: 20 indicators across three categories. That’s a screen, separate from the ratings in our published notes. We also meet companies, visit sites and attend investment conferences here and overseas.
Screens sort a large amount of information and point us to the questions worth asking. A company can look inexpensive because the market expects weaker earnings, or expensive because investors expect its competitive position and cash generation to hold up. The initial comparison raises a question about value, and the answer depends on the underlying business and the assumptions reflected in the price. Two funds or ETFs can look alike on exposure or past returns while holding quite different investments and taking different risks.
Moving from a broad screen to deeper coverage
Coverage moves with opportunity. Index weight doesn’t decide what we research, and neither does a quota for each sector. A company that previously attracted little attention becomes worth investigating when its valuation changes or new information emerges. The case for continuing detailed work fades as the opportunity changes or other questions become more important, and the company leaves coverage.
Because the research feeds our own portfolios, the test for spending time on a company is whether we’d be prepared to invest in it. Market prices create questions too: a company’s operating outlook can stay broadly the same while a substantial fall in its share price changes the return available.
What deeper coverage means
For a company, full coverage means the business model, operating performance, financial statements, capital allocation, management, industry developments, forecasts and valuation, and the uncertainty around each.
For a managed fund, it means the investment process and the people running it, together with the portfolio, its exposures, liquidity, costs and behaviour in different markets. Manager meetings and due diligence let us test the claims made about a strategy, and we check what we’re told against the portfolio and the record.
For an ETF, it starts with how the product is built and what it actually holds, because a product’s name or asset-class label tells you little about what you’d own. Chapters 4 and 5 go further into each.
Focus Lists: keeping investments in view
We push current ideas to subscribers through our Focus Lists. The Australian and Global Equity Focus Lists set each company against the same measures: market capitalisation, forward price-to-earnings multiples and dividend yields for the next two years, forecast free-cash-flow yield, return on invested capital less the cost of capital, and share-price performance from one day to one year. The Australian list runs across sectors as different as communication services, energy, health care, technology, real estate and utilities.
The measures have to be read together. A high free-cash-flow yield can mean genuine cash generation, or a price pushed down by worries about the future. A high return on capital can sit alongside a share price that already reflects it.
The Multi-Strategy Focus List
The Multi-Strategy Focus List does the same job for managed funds and ETFs. It groups them by the part of a portfolio they serve and gives each product’s type, management cost and a short comment from us.
Selected entries from the Multi-Strategy Focus List, 2025. Comments are as published then and aren’t current recommendations.
Products in the same group can behave very differently. A tactical income manager, an emerging-market credit ETF and a government bond portfolio all sit under fixed income, yet they take different risks and respond differently when financial conditions deteriorate.
Coverage must remain selective
We have a relatively small investment team, and the programme spans a wide range of markets and investment types. We keep continuous watch on what drives many decisions at once, such as interest rates, economic conditions and broad market valuations. Intensive work on a company, manager or security happens when the question justifies it.
Chapter 03
How we reach a view
Every note we publish has to say what drives the investment, which assumptions the conclusion rests on, and whether the price pays you for the risks. Models, market data, company disclosures, meetings and outside research help us answer that. The judgement is ours.
Working out which evidence matters
Our screens and the results season bring a company to our attention. The work is deciding what the news means. If the shares fall after a disappointing result, either the weakness is temporary and the market has marked them down too hard, or cash generation is deteriorating in a way the market hasn’t yet recognised. We need to know why the earnings disappointed before we treat the fall as an opportunity.
We meet management, visit companies and talk to industry specialists. When management explains weaker margins, we check the explanation against the reported results and conditions across the industry. Some of the evidence hasn’t reached the reported results yet: a regulatory approval still pending, or customers still deciding whether to commit (Chapter 4 opens with an example). Where a case depends on developments like these, the uncertainty goes into the view.
Using models to examine the investment case
Our models connect what we expect of a business to what it’s worth, and the drivers depend on the business. For a property-settlement platform such as PEXA, they’re transaction volumes and pricing. For a royalty company such as Deterra, they’re commodity prices, production and royalty terms.
If a forecast has margins improving, we want to know what produces it: volumes spreading fixed costs, lower expenses, or a new business turning profitable. An improvement already showing in the results is easier to test than one waiting on a launch or an approval. We also run the less comfortable case. Slower growth does modest damage to a business with flexible costs, and much more to one with heavy borrowing or fixed commitments. The model tests the assumptions; deciding which are reasonable, and how much weight the valuation deserves, is our call.
Challenging the investment case
Every view is discussed and challenged across the team before we publish it, and the people responsible for it remain accountable. Before Banyantree, members of the team worked at Morgan Stanley, Aberdeen Asset Management, RBC Capital Markets and IOOF (now Insignia Financial). Those backgrounds, across institutional funds management, sell-side research, investment banking and hybrid securities, bring different questions to the same note.
We go looking for the evidence pointing the other way: a company gaining market share while its prices come under pressure, or a fund whose strong returns came from strategies that could fall together in a sharp sell-off. We also ask whether another security offers similar prospects at a better price, and whether a simpler, cheaper product would do the same job as a fund. Where the evidence isn’t enough for a firm view, we keep investigating before we publish one.
What a published note contains
A company note puts the conclusion on the front page: the rating, the share price, the price target and the date, then a summary of the result or development and our view. The front page of our 9 April 2025 note on PEXA Group read: Buy, price A$11.26, price target A$13.43. Inside are the investment thesis, the key risks, a description of the business, and a financial summary with several years of figures and valuation multiples.
A fund or ETF review covers the manager, the strategy, the portfolio, performance against its benchmark, fees and the principal risks, and gives our rating with its date.
What our ratings mean
Each company note carries a rating and a price target, and each fund or ETF review carries a rating. The ratings in this Guide’s examples mean the following:
- Buy: we think the shares are worth materially more than the price on the note’s date, and our price target sits well above that price.
- Neutral: the price is close to our valuation. We may still like the business, but we see limited return from that price.
- Recommended (managed funds and ETFs): we think the product is a sound way to get its exposure, given the manager, the strategy, the costs and the risks.
The two company notes in this Guide show the difference in practice. PEXA’s A$13.43 target sat about 19% above its A$11.26 price, and we rated it Buy. Electronic Arts’ US$173.90 target sat about 4% above its US$167.01 price, and we rated it Neutral.
Recommended is our own rating, decided by our team. It isn’t linked to the ratings other research providers publish under the same word.
A price target is our estimate of what the shares are worth on the note’s date, and its precision shouldn’t be mistaken for certainty about future earnings or prices. A rating applies at that date and price. When the evidence or the price moves enough, we review it, and a rating can change on price alone. Chapter 7 shows how.
Chapter 04
Researching companies, listed property and hybrids
In April 2025, PEXA Group was two businesses at different stages. In Australia, about 90% of property transfers went through its exchange, and its margins were rising. In the UK, progress depended on lender approvals and a regulatory decision that hadn’t yet come. The share price had to carry both, and so did our valuation. Chapter 8 sets out that note.
Companies: the business and the price
How a company grows decides what the growth is worth. More transactions through an established platform add revenue without matching costs; PEXA’s Australian exchange, which already handled most of the country’s property transfers, had an operating EBITDA margin of 56.3%. An acquisition brings earnings along with integration work and, often, more debt.
Accounting profit can look strong while capital spending eats the cash, so we look at what’s left after the business has paid to hold its position, and at what management does with it. Acquisitions, dividends, debt reduction and buybacks each change what shareholders end up with. A buyback helps the remaining shareholders only when the company can afford it and the shares are good value.
Our company notes set out several years of earnings multiples, enterprise-value multiples and dividend yields, because no single measure fits every company. Enterprise-value measures help where debt levels differ, and cash flow where capital spending or working capital decides what’s left for shareholders. A strong business can still be a poor investment if the price already assumes the good outcome.
Listed property: assessing the assets, income and financing
An A-REIT’s value rests on its rents, the condition of its buildings, its debt and the return investors want from property. When investors want a higher return, capitalisation rates rise and valuations fall, even if rents barely move. Gearing magnifies that fall for unitholders, because what’s owed to lenders doesn’t shrink with the property values. A trust facing a wall of refinancing is worse placed than one with modest gearing and well-spread maturities.
A high distribution yield is worth having only when the income behind it survives interest costs, capital spending and vacancies. Our weekly A-REIT valuations track each trust’s price against its reported net tangible assets as rents, financing costs and prices change.
Hybrids: understanding the security before comparing the yield
With a hybrid, the terms come first. We look at where the security ranks in the issuer’s capital structure, how distributions are set and when they can be deferred or cancelled, and the conversion, redemption and call provisions. Bank capital hybrids can convert into shares or be written off if the bank gets into difficulty.
A first call date gives the issuer the option to redeem, usually subject to conditions or regulatory approval. The holder has no right to be repaid on that date. A yield quoted to the first call assumes redemption then; if the security stays on issue, distributions reset under its terms, the price can fall and the exposure to the issuer lasts longer than planned. We work out that outcome as well. An issuer’s reasons to call also change with its funding costs and prudential rules.
Those rules are changing. In December 2025 APRA finalised the removal of bank Additional Tier 1 hybrids from regulatory capital: the new framework takes effect on 1 January 2027, and APRA expects all bank AT1 to be phased out by 2032. The legal terms of existing securities, including subordination, stay as they are. For holders, call dates and what the banks issue instead become central questions. Our weekly comparison of ASX-listed hybrids sets the return at today’s price against each security’s terms and risks.
Chapter 05
Researching managed funds, ETFs and LICs
With a managed fund or ETF, we want to know what you’d actually own, how the investments are chosen and what decides the return. For an active fund that means the people, and whether the portfolio matches what they say about it. For an index ETF it means the construction rules, and an active ETF needs both. A listed investment company adds one more question, because its share price can sit well away from the value of what it holds. Each review ends in a rating, and Chapter 3 explains what Recommended means.
Understanding the manager and the strategy
A fund’s objective and mandate say what the manager is trying to do and within what limits. We then check the holdings against the approach described. A manager who talks about diversification sometimes holds positions that depend on the same economic conditions, and a strategy that looks defensive in calm markets sometimes carries liquidity exposures that dominate in a sell-off.
A strong record often rests on a few individuals whose departure would change how the portfolio is run, so we look at the team’s experience, continuity and resources. For the 60 to 90 funds we cover, an annual programme of manager meetings and due diligence lets us test what we’re told against the portfolio, the record and the risks.
Understanding the performance record
We read returns against the risks taken to earn them. For an equity manager, we separate the manager’s decisions from market, sector and style exposures. An absolute-return fund has to beat cash, and we also look at volatility, drawdowns and how it behaved when protection was needed. Returns before fees explain the strategy; investors receive what’s left after management fees, performance fees and other costs, which counts most when a complex strategy competes with simpler, cheaper ones.
A strategy’s record and a fund’s record
In June 2025, after meeting the manager, we rated the Janus Henderson Global Multi-Strategy Fund Recommended. The fund aims for cash plus 7% a year before fees, and our note said the global strategy behind it had met that objective since 2012, delivering about 7.4% a year. The Australian fund, a feeder that started in 2020, was well short of that objective: over the three years to 31 May 2025 it was behind its cash benchmark, and since it started it was only slightly ahead. Investors in the Australian fund hadn’t received the strategy’s longer record, so the two have to be read separately. Chapter 8 has the review.
ETF research: looking through to the investments
For an index ETF, we look at the rules for choosing and weighting securities. Two products with similar names can follow different indices and give quite different exposure, and a market-capitalisation index concentrates in its largest companies as they grow. An active ETF adds the manager’s decisions, which we assess alongside the holdings, costs and risks. The units trade easily on the ASX, but the bonds or shares inside them may not, and the spread on the units can widen when markets are unsettled.
Emerging-market debt through an ETF
In June 2025 we rated VanEck’s Emerging Income Opportunities Active ETF (EBND) Recommended. The listed units made emerging-market government debt easy to hold, and looking through them showed what came with the yield: an average credit rating just below investment grade, bonds in local currencies as well as hard currencies, and political risk. The manager’s decisions about countries, currencies and credit were part of what we rated. Chapter 8 has the portfolio, the record against the benchmark and the case the note made.
Listed investment companies: the portfolio and the share price
A LIC’s shares trade on the ASX at a premium or discount to the reported net tangible assets (NTA) of its portfolio. We look at what it owns, how those investments are valued, and whether the manager’s approach and costs suit the opportunity. Reported NTA can be before or after tax, and it’s only as reliable as the valuations behind it.
A discount can be an attractive entry point, and it sometimes lasts for years. A buyback narrows it only if it’s well designed and done at the right price. For income investors, we check whether the dividend comes from the portfolio’s income or from reserves and realised gains. Our weekly LIC valuations compare share prices with reported asset values.
Chapter 06
Macroeconomic research and asset allocation
On 5 November 2024, with the US election hours away, our Multi-Asset Strategy Quarterly #29 estimated that a standard Australian 60/40 portfolio had returned about 5.4% for the year to date, against the 6.4% target we’d published at the start of the year. We thought the target was still within reach. We were more cautious about long-term government bonds: the US 10-year term premium had risen about 50 basis points in six to eight weeks from a low base, with large deficits ahead under either party, and we preferred to manage duration tactically. Chapter 8 has the full note.
From economic data to investment views
We track activity, employment, inflation, policy and financial conditions across the major economies, then compare the evidence with what markets already price. Bond yields carry expectations for interest rates, equity valuations carry expectations for earnings, and credit spreads show what investors demand for default risk. A weak month of jobs data can signal a turning economy or a disruption that’s later revised. Quarterly #29 had to judge exactly that with October 2024’s payrolls. Our asset-allocation research works across shares, government and corporate debt, commodities, property, infrastructure, alternatives and cash, and weighs the balance of possible outcomes against the price of each exposure.
What changes the relative attraction of an asset class?
An economic forecast and an investment conclusion answer different questions. The first is about activity, prices and policy; the second is about what an exposure is worth at today’s price.
For government bonds, a rise in long-term yields can come from higher expected short-term rates or a larger term premium, and the two have different implications for duration. The rising US term premium in late 2024 is why we became more cautious about long bonds. In equities, stronger growth lifts expected profits and the rate used to discount them at the same time. In credit, a slowdown that helps government bonds hurts weaker borrowers. For an Australian investor, currency changes the result of any overseas exposure, so hedging is part of comparing international funds and ETFs. The conclusion can change even when the headline forecast doesn’t, and that’s why every economic view we publish carries its date.
Chapter 07
When we change our view
Electronic Arts’ second-quarter result had almost everything we’d want. Revenue beat consensus by 2.6%, GAAP earnings per share came in 25.5% above estimates, net bookings rose 14% to a second-quarter record of US$2.08 billion, and management raised its full-year guidance. On 10 December 2024 we downgraded the shares to Neutral anyway. They’d rallied to US$167.01, near the top of their 52-week range and largely in line with our revised valuation of US$173.90. We stayed positive on the business, with its sports franchises, the push into mobile and the margin gains we expected through FY27, but most of that was already in the price.
Source: Banyantree Investment Group, Electronic Arts In-depth Research Note, 10 December 2024. The Neutral rating and US$173.90 target are from that date.
A published view records what we thought and why, at the information and price available that day. New evidence can change it, and so can the price alone.
What has changed in the investment case?
When we return to an earlier view, we start from the original research: its forecasts, valuation, principal risks and the assumptions that mattered most. We compare them with what has happened since and decide whether the conclusion still holds.
The importance of a development depends on that original case. A competitor cutting prices changes the outlook for margins. An acquisition adds borrowing and operating risk. A delayed approval pushes back revenue from an expansion, and if much of the value rests on that expansion, the valuation suffers even while the core business performs well.
A better-than-expected result can strengthen a view without moving the valuation much, and a quieter announcement can call for a full reassessment if it undermines an important forecast. The direction of the latest news is only part of the decision. We need to know what it changes and what investors are now paying for the expected outcome.
When improving results lead to a more cautious recommendation
Electronic Arts wasn’t a one-off. We’d reiterated our Buy on APA Group late in 2024, when its dividend yield looked attractive. In the 2025 half-year results season, its earnings (EBITDA) grew 9.1%, which supported our view of its inflation protection, and management reaffirmed its distribution guidance. With the securities trading largely in line with our revised valuation, we downgraded to Neutral. In the same season we moved nib Holdings to Neutral after its margins came back from unusually high levels.
Source: Banyantree Investment Group, results-season emails to subscribers, 2025. Edited extracts.
When a movement in price creates a new opportunity
A substantial fall in price works the other way. If the underlying investment is still sound, a lower price offers a better expected return. A falling price can also reflect a genuine deterioration in earnings or financing that hasn’t yet shown up in reported results. Our April 2025 Buy on Deterra Royalties (Chapter 1) followed a fall in its shares, and the recommendation came from the valuation and the risks we identified, with the fall as the prompt.
Reconsidering a fund or ETF
For a managed fund, a change in view comes from its performance or from the strategy itself. We judge performance against the fund’s objective and the risks it was meant to take: a manager trading around corporate events struggles when there are few of them, and a long-duration bond fund loses value as yields rise, even if every issuer pays. Our Janus Henderson note, for instance, expected the strategy to do best when corporate activity is high and markets sell off sharply (Chapter 8).
Strategies change too. A lead portfolio manager leaves, the fund takes exposures that differ from those we assessed, or its leverage, liquidity, fees or constraints change. We ask whether it’s still the same strategy in the respects that mattered to our view. For an ETF, we ask the same question when its index, holdings, credit quality, duration or fees change.
Revisiting economic and market views
Economic data gets revised and policy changes course. Quarterly #29 records what we thought before the 2024 US election result was known, and we read it against what followed without pretending we knew the outcome. A changed forecast doesn’t automatically invalidate the earlier analysis; we need to know what the new information says about the assumptions.
Disagreement, uncertainty and getting something wrong
Some of our judgements will prove wrong. When one does, we work out which part failed: whether the forecast was too optimistic, or the world changed in a way the evidence at the time couldn’t show. The answer tells us what to weigh differently next time.
A change in conditions is different from an error in the original information or calculations. The first may call for a revised view. If we find a material error in published research, we may correct, update or withdraw it, and tell the people who received it where appropriate.
We keep the research and models behind each view, so we can later check what we knew, what we missed and what really changed the case. Disagreement inside the team, about how much a development matters or which assumptions will hold, sharpens the view, and responsibility for the conclusion stays clear.
Communicating a revised assessment
When a material conclusion changes, we explain why from the evidence and analysis. A company result can lead to a revised note with updated forecasts and valuation, a change at a fund manager to further due diligence, and a market development to a Quick Update. During results season, our emails list each company we’ve covered with its rating and the developments that mattered, with the full reports attached. Earlier notes stay in the archive, so you can set the original assumptions beside the newer evidence and judge whether the change follows from it.
Chapter 08
Selected research, 2024–2025
Here are edited accounts of five pieces of research we published between November 2024 and June 2025: a quarterly strategy note written before the US election result was known, two company notes, an ETF review and a managed fund review. Each source line says what was left out and where outside figures came from. We chose them to show different kinds of research. They’re a selection from our record, and each stops at its publication date. Ratings, prices and targets are from the dates shown, and Chapter 3 explains what the ratings mean.
Multi-Asset Strategy Quarterly #29
- Published
- 5 November 2024
- Research
- Macroeconomic and asset-allocation research
- Written
- Before the US presidential election result was known
The position before the election
When we issued Quarterly #29, the United States was approaching the final hours of its presidential election. The election and the Federal Reserve had been the main influences on markets during 2024. Equities had delivered strong returns, particularly in the United States, and the economy had proved more resilient than many investors expected earlier in the year.
By our estimates, a standard Australian 60/40 multi-asset strategy had returned about 5.4% for the year to date. That was still below the 6.4% target we’d published at the start of the year, and we thought the target remained within reach.
The note said plainly that it wasn’t taking a position on who would win. It set out what a decisive result either way might mean for markets.
The scenarios were conditional, published before the election result was known, and carried no probabilities.
The note was cautious about bonds under either scenario. Government borrowing requirements and fiscal conditions were relevant regardless of which party won.
What historical elections could tell us
The note also looked back over US elections since 1928. A fall in the S&P 500 in October had usually come before a change of party in the White House, and November and December had tended to be good months for US shares. The samples were small, so we treated them as context for a possible strong finish to the year, alongside valuations and the economy, and as no more than that.
The October employment report looked exceptionally weak
The most recent US employment release had been disappointing. Non-farm payrolls increased by only 12,000 in October, compared with expectations of about 100,000. The report had also been affected by unusual circumstances, including hurricanes and industrial action: the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ household survey counted about 512,000 people with jobs who were off work because of bad weather.
At the same time, revisions had reduced reported employment growth for the preceding two months by a combined 112,000 jobs, and job openings tracked by Indeed, LinkUp and JOLTS kept falling from their post-pandemic highs. Taken together, the evidence supported the view that the US labour market was cooling. We didn’t regard the single payroll release as evidence that a severe downturn was under way.
The IMF expected global growth of about 3.2% in both 2024 and 2025, compared with 3.3% in 2023. It had raised its expectations for the United States in response to stronger economic data. Conditions in the euro area were less encouraging, and Germany continued to face higher energy costs and weakness in parts of its manufacturing industry, including the car industry.
Investors had become much more confident about a soft landing
Market expectations had shifted sharply over the preceding year. The Bank of America fund manager survey cited in Quarterly #29 showed that expectations of a hard economic landing had fallen from about 30% to 8% over 12 months.
Bank of America Global Fund Manager Survey, as cited in Quarterly #29. The percentages describe investors’ stated expectations at the time.
When most investors already expect a favourable economic outcome, that expectation is usually reflected in valuations. Our valuation tables showed US equities starting to look expensive again. The note also cited Bloomberg data showing that, over the previous three months, US companies with the lowest effective tax rates had outperformed those with the highest. That was worth noticing, because companies already paying relatively little tax stood to gain least from the tax cuts being proposed, and it suggested the “Trump bump” might be exaggerated for equities. History still favoured a positive finish to the year, from a less attractive starting point.
Bond markets presented a different problem
We were more cautious about longer-term government bonds. By early November 2024, the US 10-year Treasury term premium had risen by about 50 basis points over six to eight weeks.
Our concern was that the increase had happened quickly while the term premium remained low by historical standards. That left room for investors to demand still more compensation for lending to the US government for long periods. The US fiscal outlook reinforced the concern: we expected substantial deficits and growing government debt under either administration.
In the note’s words: “We prefer to be tactical with duration at this moment.”
The investment view we published
Our view was that equities could keep rising through the end of the year, while longer-term government bonds called for a tactical approach to duration. Those views were written before the election outcome was known, so the economic, valuation and bond-market arguments had to stand on their own.
Source and scope: Banyantree Investment Group, Multi-Asset Strategy Quarterly #29, 5 November 2024, citing Bloomberg, BCA Research, Bank of America, FactSet, the IMF and the US Bureau of Labor Statistics. Edited extract; the full report, charts and valuation tables aren’t reproduced. The 60/40 figures describe a standard Australian multi-asset strategy, and they aren’t the returns of a Banyantree portfolio.
Company research: Electronic Arts
- Published
- 10 December 2024
- Research
- Global equities, in-depth note
- Rating
- Neutral (downgraded)
- Price
- US$167.01
- Price target
- US$173.90
Chapter 7 tells why we downgraded Electronic Arts after a strong quarter. The note made the case in its own terms. Management had lifted its full-year net bookings guidance to US$7.5–7.8 billion, from US$7.3–7.7 billion, and we expected margins to keep expanding through FY27.
Electronic Arts had strong positions in major gaming franchises. These businesses earn revenue well beyond the initial sale of a game, through live services, additional content and continuing customer engagement. The investment thesis gave the reasons for Neutral, starting with the price: “Share price is trading largely in line with our updated valuation.” The rest described a business we still liked:
- long-term growth in online gaming and esports;
- strong franchises in Madden NFL, EA SPORTS FC, The Sims, College Football, Apex Legends and Battlefield;
- new releases that had surprised on the upside, such as College Football 25;
- opportunities in mobile advertising, though not without execution risk;
- solid free cash flow and a strong balance sheet, with room for buybacks;
- possible acquisitions.
The note listed the risks to that view: new competition and new products from rivals; key franchises or new releases failing to attract players or meet growth expectations; disruption from cloud gaming; adverse regulatory change; reliance on a small group of games for revenue and earnings; disruption to mobile growth, for example if smart glasses displaced smartphones; and the loss of content licensing agreements.
The research kept our view of the company’s prospects separate from our recommendation on the shares at that particular price. From there, the things to follow were the franchises and new releases, mobile, operating margins, free cash flow and the share price itself.
Source and scope: Banyantree Investment Group, Electronic Arts In-depth Research Note, 10 December 2024. Edited extract; the financial summary, which the note sources to BTIG, Company and Bloomberg, isn’t reproduced. The Neutral rating, price and target are from that date.
Company research: PEXA Group
- Published
- 9 April 2025
- Research
- Australian equities, in-depth note
- Rating
- Buy (maintained)
- Price
- A$11.26
- Price target
- A$13.43
We maintained our Buy on PEXA Group on 9 April 2025, with the shares near the bottom of their 52-week range of A$10.65 to A$15.22. The two operations were at very different stages of development. Australia provided a dominant market position and improving operating results. The UK offered a potentially substantial opportunity, but progress depended on approvals, bank engagement and adoption of PEXA’s technology.
The established Australian business
PEXA operated Australia’s leading electronic property settlement network. The platform allowed conveyancers, lawyers, financial institutions and other participants to lodge documents with land registries and complete financial settlement electronically. About 90% of property transfers nationally were being completed through the exchange, an increase of two percentage points from the previous corresponding period, after it went live in Tasmania and gained share in Western Australia and Queensland.
On a pro forma basis, first-half group revenue increased 12% year on year to A$202.5 million. Operating EBITDA rose 30% to A$73.2 million, and the operating EBITDA margin expanded about 520 basis points to 35.9%. The core PEXA Exchange business grew revenue by 8.7%, supported by modest transaction-volume growth, CPI-linked pricing and a more favourable transaction mix, and its operating EBITDA margin rose to 56.3%.
Our thesis rested on that dominant position, the exchange’s margins and cash flow, the protection that CPI-linked pricing gave against inflation, and room to expand into new markets such as the Northern Territory and into new segments.
The UK opportunity was less developed
The UK government supported digitising the property market, and we saw the opportunity as highly attractive. Progress, however, had been slower than expected, for reasons largely outside management’s control. PEXA was engaged with all the UK’s Tier 1 lenders, and several were progressing through internal approvals, but their decision-making, risk-management and procurement processes were taking longer than management had anticipated.
The Bank of England was also upgrading its real-time gross settlement system, which limited opportunities to test the connections between PEXA’s payment systems and the banks. And PEXA had applied to the Financial Conduct Authority in 2024 for approval to launch its sale-and-purchase product. Such approvals can typically take 12 months, and management expected it in the second half of 2025, although the timing remained with the regulator.
What the financial forecasts assumed
The note’s financial summary, which it sources to BTIG, Company and Bloomberg, had EBITDA growing faster than revenue through FY2027, so the case depended on operating improvement as well as growth.
Balance sheet, risks and our assessment at the time
Strong operating performance and lower capital expenditure allowed the company to reduce leverage to 1.9 times, from 2.9 times in the previous corresponding period. The board also announced an on-market share buyback of up to A$50 million, and FY25 guidance was reaffirmed. The thesis counted the UK as significant upside and noted that a new chief executive brought a fresh perspective to the strategy.
The risks we listed were competitive pressure on margins, a data breach or cyber-attack, regulatory change, input costs PEXA couldn’t pass on, a weaker Australian housing market or deep recession, and international expansion that failed to earn attractive returns and dragged on the group. We judged the quality of PEXA’s business model and market position highly attractive in an uncertain economy, and maintained the Buy.
Source and scope: Banyantree Investment Group, PEXA Group In-depth Research Note, 9 April 2025. Edited extract; the financial summary, which the note sources to BTIG, Company and Bloomberg, isn’t reproduced. The Buy rating, price and target are from that date.
ETF research: VanEck Emerging Income Opportunities Active ETF (EBND)
- Published
- 10 June 2025
- Research
- ETF research
- Rating
- Recommended
- Unit price
- A$10.43
We rated EBND Recommended on 10 June 2025. Our view was that emerging-market debt was underrepresented in investor portfolios, despite its yield, its diversification from developed-market bonds and its relatively low correlation to Australian bonds. EBND was actively managed across emerging-market bonds and currencies, including local-currency and hard-currency debt, and we saw it as an attractive way to hold the asset class. The case also rested on a structural shift: emerging economies had been running current-account surpluses since the Asian and Russian crises, while developed economies ran deficits.
What the portfolio held
Portfolio characteristics from VanEck, as reported in our note.
Individual country exposures were below 10%. The largest were Malaysia at 6.8%, Thailand at 6.3%, Brazil at 5.8%, South Africa at 5.5%, China at 5.3% and Poland at 5.1%, and about 86% of the portfolio sat in the category described as “Government Activity”. Spreading the portfolio across countries reduced dependence on any one of them, although global interest rates, the US dollar, capital flows and investor risk appetite can move many emerging-market bonds at the same time.
The record against the benchmark
Performance from VanEck, as reported in our note, which doesn’t say whether the returns are before or after fees. The benchmark blends two J.P. Morgan emerging-market government bond indices. Past performance isn’t a reliable indicator of future performance.
The fund had materially outperformed its benchmark over three and five years. In the note’s comparison of fixed-income categories, global high yield (hedged to Australian dollars) and EBND had the best Sharpe ratios, a measure based on volatility that can understate losses from defaults or a liquidity squeeze. The positives also included an experienced team and active management that index-tracking funds don’t offer.
Against that, the note named two risks: credit risk, the chance of capital losses from defaults, and political risk, including rising geopolitical tensions. The portfolio’s average rating of BB+ sat just below investment grade, and an average can hide weaker issuers.
Source and scope: Banyantree Investment Group, ETF Research, VanEck Emerging Income Opportunities Active ETF (EBND), 10 June 2025. Portfolio and performance figures from VanEck, as reported in the note. Edited extract. The Recommended rating and figures are from that date.
Managed fund research: Janus Henderson Global Multi-Strategy Fund
- Published
- 19 June 2025
- Research
- Managed fund research
- Rating
- Recommended
- Manager meeting
- 17 June 2025
- Fund size
- A$178.8m (May 2025)
Our June 2025 research looked at the Janus Henderson Global Multi-Strategy Fund, an absolute-return strategy that seeks returns from several investment approaches while reducing dependence on conventional equity and bond markets. We rated it Recommended two days after meeting the manager. The note’s opening judgement was that it would suit investors worried about price volatility in traditional asset classes who wanted less correlation to equities, bonds and some alternatives.
Where the returns come from
The fund’s stated objective is cash plus 7% a year before fees. It’s an Australian feeder into a global multi-strategy fund that has run for more than a decade. The note said the strategy had met its objective since 2012, and that the team had delivered about 7.4% a year. Six strategies run independently, each with its own specialist portfolio managers:
- convertible arbitrage, from mispricing in convertible bonds;
- event-driven investing, around corporate transactions and changes in capital structures;
- equity market neutral, long and short across European shares;
- price pressure, providing capital when others need liquidity;
- risk transfer, from supply and demand imbalances in derivatives markets;
- protection against extreme sell-offs.
The note named the conditions in which the fund does best: plenty of corporate activity and sharp sell-offs.
What protection costs
The point the note stressed was protection. For strategies like this, protection can cost anywhere from 1% to 3% a year, and it often comes at the expense of returns. In the note’s words, protection “hasn’t detracted from returns”, which it called a strong outcome that spoke to the investment process and the portfolio managers’ skill. The note didn’t say which return series it meant; the Australian fund’s own record is below. Over time, it said, investors should expect protection to cost about 0.5–1.0% a year, still below the typical range. The research also discussed interest-rate derivatives, including long swaption positions, intended to limit losses if interest rates rose.
The Australian fund’s own record
At 31 May 2025, the fund’s volatility was 3.9%, its correlation to global equities 0.03 and its beta 0.01. The minimum suggested timeframe was three to five years. The fund charged a management expense ratio of 1.04% a year plus a 20% performance fee, and offered daily liquidity.
Performance from Janus Henderson, as reported in our note, which doesn’t say whether the returns are before or after fees. The benchmark is the Bloomberg AusBond Bank Bill Index. The Australian fund started in 2020; the 7.4% a year is the underlying strategy’s record since 2012. Past performance isn’t a reliable indicator of future performance.
Against its objective of cash plus 7% a year before fees, the Australian fund fell well short, whether the reported returns are before or after fees: over three years it was behind cash itself, and since it started it was only slightly ahead. The case the note made rested on the strategy’s record since 2012, its protection and its team, so the fund’s record and the strategy’s have to be read separately.
The people responsible for the strategies
The note judged the team well resourced: 19 experienced portfolio managers across the strategies, including two lead portfolio managers, one in London and one in Denver. The risks it named were strategy selection failing to produce returns, the extra risk and complexity of derivatives, and the departure of a lead portfolio manager or significant turnover in the wider team.
Source and scope: Banyantree Investment Group, Managed Fund Research, Janus Henderson Global Multi-Strategy Fund, 19 June 2025; manager meeting 17 June 2025. Fund data and performance from Janus Henderson, as reported in the note. Edited extract. The Recommended rating and figures are from that date.
Reading the historical record
You may disagree with the conclusions in any of these five examples. Their dates, assumptions and comparative figures give you something concrete to challenge, and the full notes are in our research archive.
Chapter 09
Using the research
Our research works alongside your own analysis, within an investment committee or as another view on investments you already hold. The work comes from the same investment team that manages our clients’ portfolios, and you don’t need to use Managed Accounts to subscribe. How you use it depends on the decisions you’re responsible for.
Who uses it, and how
Advisers and AFSLs use our notes in portfolio construction and research decisions. Investment committees and family offices value direct access to the authors and a retained record of what changed, when and why. Institutions use the research to complement their own teams and to inform allocation and oversight. Brokers and trading platforms use it for independent perspectives and trade ideas that fit their workflow.
Putting our research alongside your own
If you already follow a company closely, you’ll have your own forecasts and valuation, and the useful differences are often found in the assumptions. Our April 2025 PEXA note separated an established Australian business from a slower, less certain expansion in the UK. Agreeing with us on Australia while expecting slower adoption in the UK would change your earnings forecasts and the valuation you place on the company.
Using the research in investment committees
Investment committees often need a wider set of questions than whether a security looks attractively valued. A fund with a useful strategy still has to fit the portfolio’s liquidity needs. An attractive yield comes with credit risk the committee has to be willing to take. An outlook that supports one asset class can create difficulties for another.
Our EBND review, for instance, sets the fund’s yield, credit quality, duration and country exposures side by side, so you can test them against your committee’s limits and alternatives. The quarterly research does the same for the broader outlook. Your committee makes the decision; the note lays out the evidence and assumptions for it to test.
Returning to earlier research
Your subscription includes our research archive in the client portal. You can go back to an earlier note to see the original case, the figures available at the time and the assumptions behind the conclusion, and set them beside later results or a later note.
The archive holds what we’ve published. Our internal models, drafts and team discussions stay with us, but you can ask us about the reasoning behind any published conclusion.
Questioning the people who wrote the research
You speak directly with the investment team that wrote the research. We don’t have a relationship manager between you and the people doing the work.
Ask us why we used a particular earnings assumption, how we judged a company’s refinancing risk or what would make us reconsider a recommendation. If you have evidence pointing another way, such as a view that margins will be lower than we expect, we’ll talk through what that does to the valuation. The same goes for a fund review or an economic view, including information that has emerged since we published. The Monthly Investment Series is another place to put questions to us.
You can also suggest subjects for us to look at, and subscribers sometimes bring us information worth weighing. We decide what we cover and publish, according to the programme’s priorities.
Chapter 10
Subscription, independence and conflicts
Our research subscription and our discretionary portfolios are separate services, and we earn fees from both. Who pays a research firm and who owns it shape how independent its research is. This chapter sets out where our revenue comes from, what we’re not paid for, and where conflicts remain.
The research subscription
The standard subscription costs A$300 plus GST per adviser, per month. That covers the whole research programme, with no separate subscriptions or add-ons by asset class. You receive the scheduled publications, additional research when a question needs it, the Monthly Investment Series, access to the research archive through the client portal, and the ability to speak directly with our investment team. If your organisation needs a different arrangement, talk to us about eligibility and terms.
Under our Terms of Service, you can use the research for your own or your organisation’s internal purposes. Unless the law or an agreement allows it, you can’t reproduce, republish or distribute it to others.
Why we charge a flat subscription
Your subscription pays for the research programme, and the fee is the same whatever we conclude. A Buy, a Neutral and a note arguing against an idea all earn us the same, and none of it depends on what you go on to buy or sell.
So the research is useful whether or not it leads to a transaction. Our Electronic Arts note of December 2024 supported the business case and still concluded that the share price already reflected most of the improvement. Fund reviews do the same, raising concerns about fees, liquidity or the exposures behind the returns even when the strategy is attractive.
Who pays us, and who does not
Research subscriptions and discretionary portfolio-management fees are our two sources of client revenue.
Fund managers, issuers and platforms don’t pay us for research coverage, inclusion or placement. We receive no rebates, shelf-space payments or referral fees. We don’t operate a broking, investment-banking or capital-raising business.
So a fund manager can’t buy coverage or a favourable rating, and we earn nothing extra when you act on a recommendation. Those exclusions remove some reasons to favour one provider or security. Other conflicts remain, and the sections below cover how we handle them.
Commercial interests remain as well. We want subscribers to find the work worth paying for, and our portfolio-management revenue grows with the assets we manage, so we have an interest in winning and keeping mandates as well as subscriptions.
Owned by the people doing the work
Banyantree is 100% owned by its investment team. No parent company or outside shareholder sets a house view for us to follow. The people writing the research and managing the portfolios also carry the firm’s reputation and economics.
We draw heavily on outside data and research, and the conclusions stay ours.
Ownership also concentrates responsibility in a small team. Shared research, models and decision records let others in the firm revisit earlier assumptions and follow the reasoning behind a view. The work still depends on the judgement of a few people, and key-person risk is something you should weigh when you assess the subscription.
Research and the portfolios we manage
The same team writes our research and manages the portfolios. A research subscriber reads our view and decides what to do with it. For a managed portfolio, we make that decision within the client’s mandate. The research is written by people who act on it, and the controls below are how we manage the conflict that creates.
That raises a question of timing. A portfolio decision can be made while the research behind it is still being written, before the note goes out. Publication can also move a less liquid stock while portfolios are trading it. So we control who sees research before release, how publication and trading are sequenced, and how the team trades for itself.
No client gets preferential access to research because of a commercial interest, and portfolio decisions made while a note is being written follow our Conflicts of Interest Policy.
Front-running, misuse of client order information and allocation that favours one client for an improper reason aren’t permitted.
Fairness between clients needs the same care. When several portfolios want the same thinly traded stock at once, there may not be enough liquidity to fill every order on the same terms. We allocate under set procedures and record material decisions. Existing holdings and trading interests must not dictate what we publish: research conclusions have to stand on their evidence and valuation.
A research recommendation and a portfolio decision
A favourable view doesn’t put a stock in every portfolio we manage, and a Neutral rating doesn’t force every holding to be sold. Mandates differ in what they permit, some portfolios already carry similar risks, and liquidity, existing positions and the alternatives all affect the decision.
Our Investment Research and Managed Accounts services are available separately. As a research subscriber, you decide how the research applies to your objectives, portfolio and obligations. Under a Managed Accounts mandate, we take the investment decisions delegated to us within the agreed boundaries. You can use either service, or both.
Personal interests and other relationships
We speak with company management and fund managers because they help us understand a business or a strategy, and they have their own interest in how they’re seen by investors. We check what they tell us against the results, the portfolio and our own analysis. If we ask one of them to check facts in a draft, the check is limited to facts, never our opinion, valuation or conclusion.
Other conflicts can come from personal holdings, outside interests, gifts, counterparties and confidential information. If a conflict can’t be managed properly, the activity doesn’t go ahead. Our Conflicts of Interest Policy and Research Independence Policy set out how we manage them.
Under those policies, our people’s holdings and trades are subject to personal trading requirements, which may include disclosure, pre-clearance, restricted securities, holding periods or trading restrictions. Their pay isn’t designed to reward a particular research conclusion or to favour an issuer, fund manager or transaction. When a company meeting or market sounding exposes us to non-public information, we apply controls before the affected research or trading goes ahead, which may include restricting access, information barriers, restricted lists or trading restrictions.
The limits of the research
Our material may include investment views, general advice or recommendations. Unless we expressly say otherwise, it’s general in nature and doesn’t take into account any particular person’s objectives, financial situation or needs. The research subscription is for wholesale clients and professional investors. Forecasts and valuations rest on assumptions that can prove wrong, which is why every note carries its date. Read each note with its own disclosures, including any material interests or relationships it declares. The investment decision is yours, unless you’ve delegated it to us under a Managed Accounts mandate.
Examine the research for yourself
The best test of the research is to use it. Ask us for a 30-day trial, read the notes alongside your own work and put your questions to the people who wrote them. We confirm eligibility, access and the trial’s terms when we set it up.
Read this Guide with our Disclaimer.